Goodyear Marathon vs Carlisle Radial Trail RH

The tire thread sticky was 3 years old and I did a search too, thought I'd just ask.
These are my local choices for replacing my tires after my blowout last week.

225/75R15

Goodyear Marathon load range D

Carlisle Radial Trail RH load range D

The goodyears are $7 more per tire but that doesn't matter to me, I just want to put the best tire on.

Thanks.